.2309131009550.jpg)
Getting married to the person you love should feel joyful, yet for many couples in San Diego, the next question is terrifying: how do we prove to cthat our marriage is real? You might have a valid marriage certificate, a few photos, and shared memories, but still feel unprepared when you hear stories about difficult interviews and denials. That gap between what you know is true and what you can document is where a lot of anxiety begins.
Many couples in San Diego come to us worried that they do not have the “right” paperwork, or that something in their past, such as a prior visa overstay or criminal case, will cause officers to doubt their relationship. Others are confused by long lists of suggested documents they see online, and do not know what actually matters at the San Diego USCIS field office. They want concrete answers, not generic advice, and they want to understand how an officer will see their file and their life together.
At Rodriguez Law Firm, we bring more than 25 years of immigration and criminal defense experience in San Diego to these exact questions. Our founding attorney’s background as a former police officer and criminal investigator shapes how we build marriage cases, because proving a bona fide marriage is really about presenting credible, well-organized evidence. In this guide, we walk through how USCIS evaluates bona fide marriages, what kinds of proof carry the most weight, how to handle red flags, and how you can prepare for interviews and responses in the San Diego jurisdiction.
Strengthen your spouse visa or green card case—learn how to prove a bona fide marriage in San Diego. Call (619) 332-1703 now or reach out online for guidance.
What “Bona Fide Marriage” Really Means in San Diego Immigration Cases
In immigration law, a bona fide marriage is not simply any marriage that is legally valid under California law. USCIS is looking for proof that both spouses intended to build a life together at the time of marriage, not to use the marriage primarily to obtain an immigration benefit. That focus on intent is critical, because officers evaluate whether your day-to-day reality matches the picture of a genuine shared life, not just whether your paperwork looks neat.
USCIS applies a totality of the circumstances analysis, which means there is no single magic document that proves a bona fide marriage. Instead, officers weigh all the evidence together, including how long you have been together, whether you live at the same address, whether you share financial responsibilities, how your families and friends recognize your relationship, and whether your story is consistent across forms, documents, and interviews. Two couples can submit very different sets of documents, and both can be approved, or both can be questioned, depending on how those pieces fit together.
The San Diego field office follows the same national standards, but certain patterns tend to draw more questions here. For example, short relationships that moved quickly to marriage, large age differences, prior immigration violations, or criminal histories can prompt officers to look more closely at the marriage intent. They may also look for consistency across prior filings, such as previous non-immigrant visas or earlier marriage-based petitions, and compare those records to your current story. Our role is to help you understand how your particular facts will appear through that lens before you file.
Because our practice at Rodriguez Law Firm focuses on adjustment of status and other immigration matters in San Diego, we have seen how these standards are applied in real cases. We approach your file like an investigator, asking the same kinds of questions we know officers will ask, then planning your evidence and interview preparation around that reality. This insider perspective often makes the difference between a scattered submission and a file that tells a clear, credible story of a bona fide marriage.
Core Categories of Evidence That Prove a Bona Fide Marriage
Most couples want to know, very practically, what documents they should collect to prove their marriage is real. Instead of handing you a generic checklist, it helps to think in terms of categories of proof that show different parts of your shared life. Officers usually group evidence around where you live, how you handle money, how you support and care for each other, and how your relationship shows up in the world around you.
Proof of joint residence is one of the strongest indicators that you are building a life together. In San Diego, this might include a lease or mortgage in both names for an apartment or house, utility bills sent to both of you at the same address, or letters addressed to each spouse at that address over time. If you live with family, letters from landlords or relatives, along with mail for both of you at the same home, can help show that you truly share that space and treat it as your household.
Joint financial documents carry significant weight because they show that you trust each other with money and long-term obligations. Examples include joint bank account statements, credit card bills for shared accounts, joint tax returns filed as married, auto or health insurance policies listing both spouses, and retirement or life insurance policies naming each other as beneficiaries. Officers understand that not every couple chooses to merge every account, but they give considerable attention to evidence that you share financial responsibilities, such as rent, car payments, or major purchases.
Shared responsibilities and social recognition add another layer of proof. Birth certificates for children of the marriage, school or medical records listing both parents, and records of shared memberships or subscriptions all demonstrate an ongoing life together. So do photos that show a timeline of your relationship, for example holidays, birthdays, trips, and time with each other’s families, not just posed wedding pictures. The same is true of travel itineraries taken together, messages showing regular communication over time, and affidavits from friends or relatives who can describe specific experiences with you as a couple.
At Rodriguez Law Firm, we help couples prioritize and organize these categories so the strongest evidence is easy for an officer to see. Drawing on our investigative background, we often spot proof clients did not think to include, such as workplace emergency contact forms, gym memberships, or even repair invoices that show how you handle household issues together. This kind of detail can make your file look less like a random stack of papers and more like a consistent picture of a bona fide marriage.
How To Build a Strong Evidence Package When You Lack Traditional Joint Documents
Many couples in San Diego worry that they are in trouble because they do not have a lease in both names or a joint bank account. You might live with parents or roommates, get paid in cash, or keep finances separate for personal or cultural reasons. These situations are common, and they do not automatically mean your case is weak, but they do require more careful planning and creative use of other proof.
If you live with family, a landlord, or roommates, you may not appear on the main lease or utility bills. In that scenario, you can look for evidence such as letters or packages addressed to both of you at the same address, official mail like pay stubs or bank statements for each spouse showing that address, and written statements from the homeowner or roommates describing how long you have lived there as a couple. Photos taken in the home over time, especially during holidays or family events, also help anchor your shared residence and show that you are part of the household.
When finances are not formally combined, you can still show how you support each other. Couples often have patterns like one spouse paying rent while the other covers groceries, or one sending money abroad to help the other’s family. Bank or money transfer records, receipts, and written explanations can demonstrate these patterns. If you use separate accounts, evidence of regular transfers between spouses with clear descriptions can show that your financial lives are connected even without a joint account.
Alternative forms of proof become especially important for recent marriages or couples who spent time living long-distance before living together. Travel itineraries for visits, passport stamps, photos from trips, and screenshots of regular communication over time can help show a genuine relationship that developed before marriage. Affidavits from friends, employers, religious leaders, or community members in San Diego who know you as a couple can also carry real weight if they describe specific observations, such as seeing you at events together or knowing about shared plans and responsibilities.
We work with many couples who fit one or more of these nontraditional patterns. Our approach at Rodriguez Law Firm is to map out your relationship on a timeline and then look for proof that supports each stage, even if it does not fit a standard checklist. We then help you organize the evidence with a simple index and clear labels so that an officer reviewing your San Diego case can quickly follow your story instead of hunting for clues in a pile of unrelated documents.
Red Flags That Trigger Extra Scrutiny and How To Address Them
Some marriages raise more questions for USCIS than others, even when the relationship is completely genuine. These red flags do not mean your case will be denied, but they do signal that officers are likely to look more closely at your evidence and your interview answers. Understanding how these issues appear from an officer’s perspective can help you plan and fill in the gaps before they become problems.
Common red flags in San Diego marriage cases include very short courtships before marriage, large differences in age, limited shared language, major differences in cultural or religious backgrounds, and previous marriage-based immigration petitions. Prior immigration violations, such as overstays or unlawful entries, and criminal records for either spouse can further increase scrutiny, because they raise questions about whether the primary motive for marriage was immigration relief rather than a genuine commitment. Officers also compare your current story with any past visa applications or removal orders, looking for inconsistencies.
When officers see these patterns, they tend to ask more detailed questions and expect stronger documentation. For example, a couple who married three months after meeting will want to show a dense record of communication, time spent together, and integration into each other’s lives in that period. A couple with a significant age gap or little shared language can strengthen their case with affidavits and evidence that shows real emotional and practical support, not just surface interactions. Where there are prior petitions or divorces, clear timelines and explanations help officers see that each relationship was distinct and that your current marriage stands on its own.
Red flags related to criminal history require particular care. A prior DUI, domestic violence allegation, or other criminal matter may not only have immigration consequences, it can also influence how an officer views credibility and judgment. In these situations, we review court records, police reports, and prior immigration files to understand what will appear in your USCIS file, then prepare a strategy to address those facts honestly while still focusing on the strength of your current marriage. Sometimes this includes additional rehabilitation evidence or context about events that occurred long before the relationship began.
Because Rodriguez Law Firm combines immigration practice with decades of criminal defense experience and an investigative background, we are comfortable handling these complex fact patterns. We sit down with you to identify potential red flags before filing, then plan what additional documentation, explanations, and interview preparation are needed to answer the questions we know officers are likely to ask. This proactive approach often helps couples avoid being surprised at the interview or blindsided by a Request for Evidence later.
What To Expect At Your Marriage Interview in the San Diego Field Office
For many couples, the marriage-based adjustment of status interview at the San Diego USCIS field office is the most stressful part of the process. Knowing what typically happens can take some of the fear out of the unknown. While every officer has a slightly different style, there is a common structure that most local marriage interviews tend to follow, and understanding that structure can help you feel more prepared.
On the day of your interview, you will go through security and check in at the San Diego field office, then wait for your name to be called. An officer will escort you to an interview room, place you under oath, and begin reviewing your identification and basic information from your I-130 and I-485 forms. The officer will usually confirm biographical details like names, dates of birth, addresses, and prior immigration history before asking relationship questions. They will have your entire file in front of them, including any prior visa applications and supporting evidence.
Relationship questions often start with how you met, how the relationship developed, and how you decided to marry. Officers commonly ask about the engagement, who attended the wedding, and what you did before and after the ceremony. They may also ask practical questions about your daily routines, such as who wakes up first, how you divide chores, how you handle bills, and how you spend weekends. These questions help the officer see whether your answers match each other and whether they fit the documents you submitted, such as your address and work schedules.
If an officer has concerns or sees red flags, they may ask more detailed or personal questions. In some cases, they can choose to interview you separately to compare your answers. This is sometimes referred to as a marriage fraud interview or, in older terminology, a Stokes interview. Separate interviews usually involve more specific questions about your household, property, and personal habits, and officers will carefully compare the two sets of answers for inconsistencies that cannot be explained by nerves or memory lapses.
Our clients often tell us that practicing for the interview made a significant difference in how confident they felt. At Rodriguez Law Firm, we conduct mock interviews that follow a similar structure to a typical San Diego marriage interview. We go over your forms, highlight any answers that might raise questions, and rehearse how to handle detailed or unexpected questions calmly and honestly. Because of our investigative background, we pay close attention to consistency, helping you spot and correct issues before you sit down with a USCIS officer.
Responding To Requests for Evidence and Notices of Intent To Deny
Even when a marriage is genuine, some couples receive a Request for Evidence or a Notice of Intent to Deny from USCIS. These letters can be frightening to open, but they are also an opportunity to strengthen your case. Understanding what they mean and how to respond can greatly affect the final outcome of your San Diego marriage-based application.
A Request for Evidence, often called an RFE, is a notice that USCIS needs more information before making a decision. In marriage cases, officers might issue an RFE if your initial evidence of a bona fide marriage was thin, inconsistent, or missing in key categories like joint residence or finances. A Notice of Intent to Deny, or NOID, is more serious. It signals that the officer is leaning toward denial based on specific concerns, such as significant inconsistencies, suspected marriage fraud, or unresolved criminal or immigration issues, but is giving you a chance to respond.
In both RFEs and NOIDs, USCIS usually lists the exact issues they see and the types of evidence they believe are missing or inadequate. A strong response requires going point by point through that list, adding new documentation, and explaining how the evidence you provide addresses each concern. For example, if the officer questioned your cohabitation, you might provide additional mail for both spouses at the same address, letters from landlords or neighbors, and a clearer timeline of when each spouse moved in. If there were inconsistencies in your testimony, you may need to clarify what led to the confusion and present a consistent narrative backed by documents.
Many couples seek legal help for the first time after receiving an RFE or NOID, because they realize that their initial submission did not fully reflect their life together. At Rodriguez Law Firm, we treat these responses almost like rebuilding the case, reviewing prior filings, interview notes where available, and the evidence on file to understand why USCIS raised concerns. We then help you gather stronger or missing proof and prepare written explanations that speak directly to the issues raised, using an organized format that makes it easier for the officer to follow and reconsider the case.
How Working With a San Diego Immigration Lawyer Strengthens Your Bona Fide Marriage Case
Proving a bona fide marriage is as much about strategy as it is about collecting documents. A San Diego immigration lawyer who understands how USCIS officers analyze evidence can review your entire relationship story through that same lens. Instead of simply asking whether you have certain documents, we look at how those documents fit together, what they say about your life, and where there might be gaps or inconsistencies that need attention.
Before filing, we typically go through your relationship timeline in detail, from how you met to the present day, and compare it to your forms, prior immigration history, and any criminal records. This process helps identify issues such as mismatched addresses, unclear dates, or missing explanations for travel or living arrangements that might confuse an officer. We then work with you to gather or create supporting evidence, such as clear affidavits, letters from landlords or employers, and additional documentation that supports your narrative.
Our combined immigration and criminal defense background is particularly valuable in cases involving arrests, prior charges, or convictions. We understand how these records appear in your immigration file and how they may affect officers’ views of your marriage and eligibility. With more than 25 years of practice and a founding attorney who previously served as a police officer and criminal investigator, Rodriguez Law Firm is accustomed to reading reports, spotting potential credibility issues, and building a more complete and accurate picture for USCIS.
We also know that communication is critical. Our bilingual team communicates in both English and Spanish, which allows many San Diego couples to fully understand the process, ask questions comfortably, and participate actively in preparing their case. For couples concerned about cost, we offer competitive fees and payment plans so that thorough preparation is more accessible. Throughout, our focus remains on building a tailored strategy for your specific situation rather than forcing your relationship into a generic template.
Talk To Rodriguez Law Firm About Your Bona Fide Marriage Case
Proving a bona fide marriage in a spouse visa or adjustment of status case is not about impressing USCIS with a thick stack of papers. It is about presenting a clear, honest, and well-documented story of the life you are building together, in a way that makes sense to the officer reviewing your San Diego file. When you understand how officers think and what evidence they rely on, you can move from fear and confusion to a plan that fits your relationship.
If you are preparing to file, waiting for an interview at the San Diego field office, or dealing with an RFE or NOID about your marriage, speaking with a local immigration attorney can help you see your case the way USCIS will. At Rodriguez Law Firm, we use our investigative approach, decades of immigration and criminal defense experience, and bilingual support to help couples organize evidence, address red flags, and prepare confidently for interviews. To talk about your situation and what proof you may need, contact us today.